Your Welcome Email Is Scary (Here’s How to Fix It)

Oct 2, 2025 | Digital Marketing, Leads Funnels, Marketing Strategy, Small Business Owner Inspiration | 0 comments

☠️ There’s something scarier than Halloween this year.

And it’s lurking in your email system.

You guessed it:

Your welcome email.

Or worse… the fact that you don’t even have one.

/

I can’t tell you how many business owners I’ve talked to who are doing so many things right.


✔️ They’re growing their list.
✔️ They’re driving traffic.
✔️ They’re running ads or posting content or promoting a lead magnet…

But the second someone signs up, all they get is:

“Thanks for subscribing.”

That’s it.

❌ No follow-up.
❌ No story.
❌ No connection.
❌ No reason to stay.

And look—I get it. It’s easy to skip this part.

But if you care about building a brand that lasts, a business that converts, and relationships that lead to real clients and referrals… You need more than a polite confirmation email.

You need a real welcome sequence.

Why Your Welcome Email Matters More Than You Think


Your welcome email is one of the most opened emails you will ever send.
That first message? It has the highest open rate across your entire list.

Which means:
You already have their attention.
Now it’s your job to do something with it.

Because if you waste that moment?
They’ll forget who you are before you ever get the chance to show them what you do.


What Happens When You Don’t Have a Welcome Sequence

Here’s what I see all the time:

  • You get new subscribers from a lead magnet, event, or ad campaign.
  • They join your list with curiosity and interest.
  • Then… nothing…
  • You finally send them an email two months later.
  • And they either unsubscribe, delete it, or ask, “Who is this?”

It’s not that your offer isn’t great.
It’s because your system didn’t support the connection… (disconnection)

Skipping this step is like hosting a dinner party… and forgetting to greet your guests.

😢 It’s awkward.
😢 It’s confusing.
😢 And it’s a missed opportunity.


What Your Welcome Sequence Should Include
A strong welcome series doesn’t have to be complicated.
But it does need to be strategic.

Here’s a simple 3-email structure that works beautifully:

✉️ Email 1: Welcome + Who You Are

  • Deliver what you promised (lead magnet, freebie, coupon, etc.)
  • Give them a warm welcome + quick intro
  • Tell them what to expect next
  • BONUS: Include a special offer or incentive that’s not on your website to make them feel like a VIP

✉️ Email 2: What You Do + Who You Help

  • Share the core transformation you offer
  • Drop a quick client win or two
  • Invite them to explore your services or learn more

✉️ Email 3: What to Do Next

  • Offer a clear call to action (book a call, grab a coupon, join your community, etc.)
  • Reinforce your credibility and values
  • Keep it simple, warm, and confident

The whole point?
Get them to know, like, and trust you.
Then show them exactly how to take the next step.


A Little Extra Magic: What to Include That Most People Don’t


Want your welcome sequence to really convert?
Give them something they can’t get anywhere else.

That could be:

  • A limited-time discount
  • A bonus offer
  • A secret page with extra goodies
  • A free mini-training or resource

Make them feel like they’ve unlocked something special.
Because the truth is—they have.

They gave you their email address.
That’s personal. That’s valuable. That’s sacred.

So treat it like it matters.
Because it does.


The Scary Truth About Skipping Email Marketing


Here’s what I want to leave you with:

In today’s world of fast trends and ever-changing algorithms, email is one of the most powerful tools you have to create consistent, aligned, profitable marketing.

  • It builds real relationships.
  • It stays top of mind.
  • It drives conversions.

But none of that happens if you skip the welcome.

So if your email system ends with “Thanks for subscribing,”
Or if you haven’t set up anything at all…

🔨 It’s time to fix that.

Need help creating a welcome sequence that actually works?

That’s exactly what we do.

Whether you’re starting from scratch or want to upgrade your current system, we’ll help you build email marketing that feels like you—and converts like crazy.

Stop scaring off your best leads.

Let’s build a system that keeps them coming back.

You May Also Like…

0 Comments

Meredith CEO of Marketing Maiden

Hey there, I´m Meredith

Founder, CEO, and Lead Marketer at Marketing Maiden.

I have a passion for helping Small Business Owners find the perfect marketing strategy for their business that will transform it into something they love doing while supporting the lifestyle they want to live!

CATEGORIES